Supply Chain VAT Fraud | The Kittel Principle

Supply Chain VAT Fraud | The Kittel Principle

HMRC faces the ongoing challenge of tackling ‘Supply Chain VAT Fraud’ and recovering unpaid VAT. VAT fraud is a common occurrence, particularly within sectors like the building industry and in a recent article titled ‘Umbrella Company Fraud,’ we detailed how this type of fraud is operated by the creation of fictitious supply chain companies in the Payroll Management Industry.

Whilst HMRC is required to prove fraudulent conduct, it is assisted by the Kittel Principle which establishes that if a taxable trader, at the point of purchase, either knew, or should have known, that he was taking part in a transaction connected with the fraudulent evasion of VAT, and that taxable trader must be regarded as a participant in that fraud. It is irrelevant whether the taxable trader made a profit on the resale of the goods.

In this situation, the taxable trader is aiding the perpetrators of the VAT fraud, effectively becoming an accomplice. KANGS has defended many clients who, unsuspectingly, became part of trading chains considered fraudulent and received VAT Assessment Notices under the Kittel principle.

Tim Thompson of KANGS considers the requirement of HMRC to prove the trader ‘knew or should have known’ of the fraudulent activity.

VAT Fraud | HMRC Reliance Upon Kittel

When denying tax, HMRC must consider:

  • was there fraudulent evasion of VAT?
  • was the transaction in question ‘connected with’ that fraudulent evasion,
  • did the trader know, or should have known, that the transaction related to the fraudulent evasion of VAT?

It is generally the case that HMRC concludes that the transaction(s) in question can be identified as fraudulent and connected to the tax loss. The trader is entitled to put HMRC to strict proof of the loss.

Knew or Should Have Known

Under Kittel, the European Court of Justice (ECJ) did not define ‘knew or should have known’ but it was confirmed to be an objective test.

HMRC will consider all trading factors considered ‘suspicious or dubious’ leading to the only reasonable explanation for the nature of the transactions that they were connected with fraudulent evasion of VAT.

Factors would include:

  • knowledge of fraud of the taxable person generally at the time,
  • existence of features relating to the transactions which should have led to questioning the presence of fraud,
  • the nature and level of any due diligence conducted,
  • ignoring suspicious indicators arising from due diligence,
  • the obvious contrived nature of the alleged trading,
  • involvement of new companies without any trading history,
  • third party or offshore requests.

Who Can I Contact for Help?

HMRC commits enormous resources in the pursuit of payment of VAT which it considers is being fraudulently evaded. It is constantly alert to any indications that fraud is being conducted such as:

  • Press coverage,
  • Reports in trade magazines emphasising the need to be aware, implying that it is a current problem,
  • Frequency of Warning Notices relating to a trader involved in suspect trading chains,
  • Personnel involved with a company with a history of involvement in suspect chains.

If you involved in, or anticipate, a dispute with HMRC, it is essential you seek expert advice and guidance. KANGS provides a wealth of experience gained from assisting clients involved with tax issues of every nature and will be pleased to hear from you.

Our Team will support you throughout the entirety of any HMRC investigation or proceedings, seeking to achieve the most satisfactory outcome available as quickly and economically as possible.

If we can be of assistance, please do not hesitate to contact our Team using the details below:

Tel:       0333 370 4333

Email: info@kangssolicitors.co.uk

We provide initial no obligation discussion at our three offices in London, Birmingham, and Manchester. Alternatively, discussions can be held through live conferencing or telephone.

Hamraj Kang

Hamraj Kang
Senior Partner

Email Phone Mobile
Tim Thompson

Tim Thompson

Email Phone
John Veale

John Veale

Email Phone
Serious Fraud, Tax & HMRC
In a previous article titled ‘Umbrella Company Fraud’, we explained the general operation of ‘umbrella companies’ and highlighted how they have increasingly attracted HMRC attention due to their increasing propensity to be involved in, or facilitation of, supply chain VAT fraud. Fraudulent exploitation of Employment Allowance (EA) and the VAT Flat Rate Scheme (FRS) enables […]
Commercial Disputes, Tax & HMRC
A ‘Loan relationship’ is a term which encompasses an extremely wide area of financial arrangements from a straight forward loan to complicated financial activity supporting trading between associated corporate bodies. Money does not have to physically change hands and the loan may be accomplished by, for example, a ‘loan note’ issued by a company for […]
Cryptocurrency, Financial Investigations, POCA
Since the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 (POCA) was introduced, essential amendments and additions have been made. These changes, which have been discussed in previous articles, enable the legislation to keep abreast of the changing requirements of society and the operation of financial markets. One such requirement is the need to cater for the arrival […]

Get in touch

Need legal assistance? Contact our experienced team for prompt and professional support.
Old map of Birmingham