Worldwide Freezing Order | Foreign Proceedings and Orders Against Unknown Individuals
Seeking a Worldwide Freezing Order (WFO), or being served with one, can mark the beginning of a lengthy period of litigation, whether you are the claimant or the defendant.
For a claimant involved in commercial litigation, a key concern may be whether the defendant’s assets will remain available until the proceedings conclude. Where there is a risk that assets may be dissipated or handled in a manner which may lead either to a reduction in their value or to them becoming untraceable, a WFO may be sought to preserve those assets and help ensure that any judgment obtained may be fulfilled.
As a result of developing technology, the substantial increase in cross-border trade and the introduction of, for example, cryptocurrencies, a Worldwide Freezing Order is becoming an increasingly important procedural tool.
In this article, Nazaqat Maqsoom of KANGS outlines the essential requirements for obtaining a WFO and introduces some interesting case law highlighting how the courts are tackling the increasing demand for WFOs.
Purpose of a Worldwide Freezing Orders
As mentioned above, WFOs are designed to secure assets located anywhere in the world and to prevent a defendant from dissipating them pending the outcome of litigation being conducted in a UK court. WFOs may assist to prevent assets from being hidden in any form of trust or shell company operated abroad and their importance is growing when dealing with civil fraud and asset recovery.
Whilst identifying assets such as bank accounts, shares, land and cryptocurrency can be reasonably straightforward, identifying specific individuals against whom a WFO is necessary may prove difficult.
The effects of a WFO on a respondent may be severe and, historically, the courts have not readily issued them, particularly where the respondent is ‘a person unknown.’ However, following Derby & Co (No3 and 4) (1990) CH65, where the Court of Appeal held that a court can order a defendant’s assets to be frozen even when situated outside of the jurisdiction, subject to certain stringent criteria, courts are now becoming more open to considering issuing a WFO against ‘a person unknown’ and in respect of foreign proceedings generally.
Obtaining a World Freezing Order
In order to obtain a Freezing Order, it is necessary to satisfy the requirements laid down by the House of Lords in the case of American Cyanamid Co (No1) v Ethicon Ltd [1975] UKHL 1 being that:
- the Claimant has a good arguable case,
- there is a real risk of dissipation of assets by the Defendant(s), and
- it is just and convenient on the balance between the parties to impose the order.
A good arguable case
The court has determined that the Claimant simply has to show an argument that is ‘more than barely capable of serious argument’ with a real chance of success on the merits.
The Court will conduct a minimal assessment of the merits and will not engage in a ‘mini trial.’
A real risk of dissipation
The Applicant is required to show that the Respondent may dissipate assets through, for example, evidence of past conduct or activity outside normal business practices. However, the courts are clear that they are not seeking to alter a defendant’s legitimate behaviour and will only step in where the specific facts require them to.
Just and convenient
It will be necessary to convince the court that it is both just and convenient to grant a Worldwide Freezing Order having taken all the circumstances into consideration and balancing potential injustice to the Respondent against the requirement to preserve the assets.
Exceptional circumstances
In the Case of Derby & Co, referred to above, it was determined that exceptional circumstances would need to exist to justify the issue of a WFO which included:
- the existence of foreign assets which were potentially at risk of dissipation. The proof of existence need not be extensive, simply sufficient to create genuine belief that assets exist to satisfy a judgment.
- the total value of assets held in England and Wales being insufficient to satisfy any judgment obtained within the claim,
- the potential for the assets to either be rendered untraceable or their value being substantially dissipated.
Effect of Service Upon a Respondent
Immediately upon the receipt of a WFO, the respondent is:
- restrained from dealing with or disposing of the frozen assets in accordance with the requirements of the Order,
- obliged to serve a sworn Affidavit setting out the nature, location and value of all worldwide assets within a stipulated period,
- co-operate with all parties to clarify the assets involved.
Failure to comply amounts to contempt of court and may be punishable by a fine, sequestration of assets or imprisonment.
A respondent will have the opportunity to challenge the Order at the ‘Return Date’ which will be given at the time of service of the Order. The WFO may be discharged if the essential elements detailed above cannot be proven or such other defence e.g. a limitation period has expired.
Important Case Law
Confirmation that WFOs may be issued to support foreign proceedings.
The Royal Bank of Scotland plc v FAL Oil Company Limited & Others [2012] EWHC 3628 (Comm) reaffirms that the Courts of England and Wales are willing to grant a WFO in support of foreign proceedings, subject to stringent conditions being met.
In that case:
- RBS made loans, subject to English law and jurisdiction, to two Liberian companies for the purchase of two ships,
- the loans were guaranteed by two further companies, both registered in the UAE and all four companies shared similar directors and shareholders. The Loan Agreements were subject to English law and jurisdiction,
- following defaults under the Loan Agreements, RBS issued proceedings in the UAE, due to difficulties in enforcing English Judgments within the foreign jurisdiction, seeking Arrest Orders against the ships and an Attachment Order against the UAE banks held by the Guarantors.
- As the UAE held no procedure/remedy akin to a WFO, RBS obtained a WFO in the English courts.
Proceedings Involving Persons Unknown
As the result of the landmark ruling in CMOC Sales & Marketing Ltd [2017] EWHC 3599 (Comm), a WFO can now be obtained against ‘persons unknown’.
In that case HHJ Waksman KC stated the change in procedure:
‘reflects the need for the procedural armoury of the Court to be sufficient to meet the challenges posed by the modern electronic methods of communication and of doing business.’
Paragraph 183 of the Judgment states that the Order forms:
‘a springboard for the grant of ancillary relief in respect of third parties which arguably could not get off the ground unless there had been a primary freezing injunction.’
In that case:
- more than $8 million was stolen from the account of CMOC Sales & Marketing when hackers broke into an email account of one of the directors,
- fraudulent payment instructions, resembling genuine instructions, which contained scanned signatures enabled the funds to be distributed across the world to fifty banks in nineteen different jurisdictions,
- the fraud was disguised by impersonating the director in email exchanges.
HHJ Waksman KC also stated:
‘injunctive relief against persons unknown will be particularly apposite where the reason they are unknown is because of their activities as hackers, just as the perpetrators in this case were hackers.’
Availability in respect of Cryptocurrency| Persons Unknown
Ion Science Ltd v Persons Unknown (unreported), 21 December 2020 (Commercial Court) CL-2020-000840
This was the first initial coin offering fraud case before English courts where the court made a WFO against persons unknown and showed that the:
- court is prepared to treat cryptoassets as property within the English law definition and
- relevant applicable law is that where the owner is domiciled. Accordingly, the court had jurisdiction to grant a WFO against persons unknown as the description of the group of fraudsters was sufficiently clear.
How Can We Assist?
It is clear that the approach of the Civil Courts to the issue of WFOs is now dramatically changing in response to, particularly, the ever- increasing volume of sophisticated cybercrime.
However, seeking a WFO still remains an extremely technical and complicated matter requiring detailed knowledge and understanding of this procedure. Our team is extremely experienced in litigation involving:
If you think you need assistance in relation to any type of Asset or Property Freezing Order, please do not hesitate to contact KANGS on the details below.
Tel: 0333 370 4333
Email: info@kangssolicitors.co.uk
We provide initial no obligation discussion at our three offices in London, Birmingham, and Manchester. Alternatively, discussions can be held through video conferencing or telephone.
Top ranked by leading legal directories Chambers UK and the Legal 500.





