Gross Negligence Manslaughter | Kangs Health & Safety Solicitors


Amandeep Murria of Kangs Solicitors explains the nature of this offence with reference to a recent tragic case brought before the Old Bailey.

Tragic Circumstances Leading to Trial | Kangs Health and Safety Team

In August 2012 a female lawyer, whilst walking past a construction site in Mayfair, London, was killed when three window frames fell on her.

Following an investigation undertaken by the Homicide and Major Crime Command and the Health & Safety Executive, charges were brought against individuals and several companies.

Sentences Imposed | Kangs Criminal Trial Solicitors

In March 2017, one of the defendants, an individual, was convicted of manslaughter by gross negligence, and offences contrary to Section 7a of the Health and Safety at Work Act, for which a twelve month prison sentence was imposed.

One of the companies prosecuted was convicted of offences contrary to Section 2 and 3 of the Health and Safety at Work Act but it could only be fined two hundred and fifty pounds because it  was  ‘dormant’ i.e not trading by that time.

It is understood that, because of the seriousness of the crime, the Judge wanted to impose a fine of £100,000, but he was unable to do so.

Definition Of Gross Negligence Manslaughter | Kangs Advisory Solicitors

This offence arises when a person dies as a result of the negligence of another and is a form of involuntary manslaughter where:

  • the defendant is ostensibly acting lawfully but
  • acts in such a way as to render the action criminal and
  • can be committed by omission.

The Test

A four stage test as to whether or not the offence has been committed is set out in case law as follows:

  • A duty of care to the deceased must have existed.
  • There must have been a breach of that duty.
  • The breach must have caused or contributed significantly to the death.
  • The breach should be characterised as gross negligence , and therefore a crime.

 Duty of Care

  • There is no general duty of care owed by one person to another.
  • A duty of care will arise from an act of a person where the requirements of foreseeability, proximity, fairness, justice and reasonableness establish such a duty.
  • The duty exists even where the defendant and the deceased were engaged in unlawful activity
  • The duty can arise from a contract of employment 

Breach of the Duty | Causation | Kangs Criminal Defence Solicitors

The test of whether a duty of care has been breached is an objective one, based upon the defendant’s position at the time of the event, and what a ‘reasonable person’ would have done in those circumstances.

The act or the omission of the accused must be connected to the death and the prosecution must prove to the satisfaction of  a jury that the breach made more than a minimum contribution to the death.

How Can We Help You? | Kangs Health & Safety Solicitors

We have a team of solicitors  experienced in conducting health and safety cases from the initial investigation/interview stages right through to trial proceedings in court.

Please feel free to contact our team through any of the lawyers named below who will be happy to provide you with some initial advice and an informal chat about any of the issues in this article which may be of interest to you.

Hamraj Kang
07976 258171 | 020 7936 6396 | 0121 449 9888

John Veale
07779 055907 | 0121 449 9888 | 020 7936 6396

Steve Micklewright
020 7936 6396 | 0121 449 9888

News insights, Serious Fraud, Services
A former Labour MP, Jared O’Mara, has received an immediate custodial sentence of four years having been found guilty, following his trial, of six counts of fraud relating to false expenses claims for work that he never carried out in respect of jobs that did not even exist. For further Press details please follow the […]
Criminal Litigation, News insights, Services
Kangs Solicitors has recently successfully defended a client facing an allegation of assault occasioning actual bodily harm arising from an incident forced upon him whilst he was simply conducting his  business, running a restaurant in London’s West End, when confronted with an unsavoury situation. Kangs Solicitors was instructed from the onset attending the interview under caution at Charing […]
Insolvency, News insights, Services
Kangs Solicitors has been instructed to defend claims against our client alleging breaches of Section 212 and 213 of the Insolvency Act 1986. The claims are being brought by the joint liquidators of our client’s company on the basis that our client allegedly knew that he and his company were participating in ‘Missing Trader Intra- Community’ Fraud’ […]

Get in touch